This week on the She Sells Differently podcast, I’m kicking off a no-fluff, no-filters series called My Burn Book of Bad Sales Advice—and the first myth I’m burning down? That discounting is a reliable way to grow your business.
Here’s the truth: discounting out of panic isn’t a strategy—it’s a stress response. One that can quietly destroy your profits, your confidence, and your brand reputation over time.
There is a better way to drive sales without undercutting your value, and it’s called strategic promotions.
Why Panic Discounting Doesn’t Work
When you discount on the fly—without a plan—you’re not just lowering your prices. You’re sending a message. And often, it’s not the one you intend.
Panic discounting tells your audience:
- “This product isn’t worth full price.”
- “I’m desperate to make a sale.”
- “You should always wait for a sale.”
Even worse? It teaches your customers to buy based on price, not value.
Over time, this creates a cycle where you feel forced to discount again and again just to keep sales coming in. That’s not sustainable—and it’s not how confident, heart-led business owners grow.
✅ What Are Strategic Promotions?
Strategic promotions are intentional, value-driven marketing campaigns that inspire action without sacrificing your brand integrity. They’re not just about boosting sales—they’re about building trust, creating loyalty, and increasing your revenue with long-term thinking.
Let’s compare the two:
| Panic Discount | Strategic Promotion |
|---|---|
| Last-minute and emotionally driven | Planned in advance with purpose |
| Lowers perceived product value | Increases perceived product value |
| Trains customers to wait for sales | Builds trust and consistent buying behavior |
| Attracts bargain hunters | Rewards loyal customers |
So instead of reacting to slow sales with a markdown, start thinking like a CEO and plan strategic promotions that reflect your worth.
🧠 The Mindset Shift: Promotions Should Reward Loyalty
One of the biggest mindset shifts I teach my clients is this:
“Sales should reward loyalty—not attract strangers.”
According to a 2023 Shopify report, repeat customers spend 67% more than first-time buyers. Yet many small businesses pour all their effort into chasing new sales through endless discounting.
What if you flipped that energy and started using promotions to deepen loyalty and strengthen your customer relationships instead?
That’s the true power of a strategic promotion.
💡 3 Types of Strategic Promotions That Actually Convert
Here are three promotional strategies you can use that build value without undercutting your pricing:
1. Value-Based Incentives
Create bundles that make sense, launch gift sets, or pair products that naturally go together. As a result, this increases your average order volume while offering a clear benefit to your customer—without touching your price point.
2. Planned Promotions
Instead of running a sale out of panic, choose a few intentional promotions per year. Think: a birthday sale tied to your founder story, a seasonal launch, or an early access event for new products. Planned promotions create excitement and consistency, which builds trust equity with your audience.
3. Early Access or VIP Exclusives
Give your most loyal customers early access to limited edition product drops or special releases. This uses urgency and exclusivity in a way that feels good and strengthens the customer relationship, all without relying on markdowns.
🛠️ Real Talk: Audit Your Last 2 Campaigns
Ask yourself:
- Did I run this promotion out of panic or strategy?
- What expectation did I set for my customers?
- Did I reward loyalty—or encourage discount chasing?
This quick audit can reveal where your promotion style might be costing you sales or brand trust.
If you’re ready to stop guessing, I created something just for you: the Product Marketing Bank—a monthly marketing system for product-based business owners who want done-for-you campaigns without relying on discounts. You can grab your first month for just $10 using the code in the show notes.
🎁 BONUS STRATEGY: Try This Instead of a Discount
At the end of this week’s episode, I shared one of my favorite no-discount sales strategies:
Offer a loyalty-first, early access product drop.
It’s simple, powerful, and totally aligned with strategic promotion.
Instead of reducing your prices, reward your VIP list or loyal buyers by giving them exclusive first access to a limited product. You build demand, make your best customers feel seen, and increase conversions—all without touching your price point.
This is the strategy I want you to try for your next launch.
🎧 Listen Now: Strategic Promotions That Convert
If you’re ready to stop spinning your wheels with random sales and start selling from confidence and clarity, this episode is for you.
👉 Tune in to the full episode of She Sells Differently on your favorite podcast platform and walk away with the mindset and tools to build promotions that truly convert—without panic discounting your way through every sales goal.
📌 Don’t Forget:
- ✨ Audit your last 2 campaigns
- ✨ Try the loyalty-first early access promo
- ✨ Grab your first month of the Product Marketing Bank for just $10 using code “BANK10“
You don’t have to discount to sell.
You just need a better plan—and I’m here to help you build it.
Resources & Links
Be one of the first 100 to access the Product Marketing Bank here.
Check out my Faire Visibility Playbook course here.
Want to get my eyes on your Faire site? Book a 1:1 Site Audit here.
Ready to learn how to automate your backend wholesale workflow? Checkout Wholesale Growth Engine
Connect with Andee Hart @ She Sells Differently
🎥 Youtube
If you enjoyed this episode:
✅Sign up for weekly reminders so you never miss an update on how to increase your sales and optimize your marketing operations without losing the personal client touch.
You can grab free resources here: https://andeehart.com/resources
✅Subscribe to the She Sells Differently Podcast, where I deliver new episodes every Wednesday.
